3
Good budget option with some trade-offs
I ordered this for my wife as she was having issues with reflected sounds from a window in her recordings. The mic screen works well for this job and has reduced this undesired sound well.
Pros:
1. Construction
Well constructed with almost all metal hardware, aside from the foam, and resin knobs.
The acoustic foam is sturdy and works well for its intended function as sound isolation.
2. Functionality
Helps to reduce reflected sound in rooms without acoustic treatment, as well as isolating the microphone from other sound sources and preventing cross talk.
3. Ease of use
Easy assembly and disassembly.
Cons
1. Weight
The mic screen is quite heavy and this makes it impractical to use with many mounting setups.
From a practical standpoint, it is only suited to being mounted vertically on top of a straight microphone stand with a wide heavy base, as it is too heavy to be mounted at the end of a standard boom arm or desk-mounted broadcasting arm.
2. Design.
The central L bracket stand is attached to the back of the mic screen using two metal thumb screws, and these have a tendency to come loose causing the bracket to sag. I have had to modify them (adding wax to the threads) to prevent this from happening.
This bracket offers very limited options for mic positioning, and it is difficult to adjust it without taking the screws out, effectively forcing you to disassemble it to do so. However, I think these issues could be improved quite easily by replacing the thumb screws with wing nuts instead.
Another improvement would also be allowing the mounting bracket to be adjusted by 90 degrees to change the weight distribution of the mic screen (so that it curves above and below the microphone rather than around the sides.)
3 Quality control
Whilst I appreciate it is a budget item, the quality control could be improved. The unit I received was covered in small damages from the manufacturer, including chipped and scratched paintwork, scuffed knobs, small areas of corrosion.
Conclusion
Overall, it works for it's intended purpose and will last a long time but there are some trade-off's with practicality and flexibility which will make it unsuitable for some setups.
Pros:
1. Construction
Well constructed with almost all metal hardware, aside from the foam, and resin knobs.
The acoustic foam is sturdy and works well for its intended function as sound isolation.
2. Functionality
Helps to reduce reflected sound in rooms without acoustic treatment, as well as isolating the microphone from other sound sources and preventing cross talk.
3. Ease of use
Easy assembly and disassembly.
Cons
1. Weight
The mic screen is quite heavy and this makes it impractical to use with many mounting setups.
From a practical standpoint, it is only suited to being mounted vertically on top of a straight microphone stand with a wide heavy base, as it is too heavy to be mounted at the end of a standard boom arm or desk-mounted broadcasting arm.
2. Design.
The central L bracket stand is attached to the back of the mic screen using two metal thumb screws, and these have a tendency to come loose causing the bracket to sag. I have had to modify them (adding wax to the threads) to prevent this from happening.
This bracket offers very limited options for mic positioning, and it is difficult to adjust it without taking the screws out, effectively forcing you to disassemble it to do so. However, I think these issues could be improved quite easily by replacing the thumb screws with wing nuts instead.
Another improvement would also be allowing the mounting bracket to be adjusted by 90 degrees to change the weight distribution of the mic screen (so that it curves above and below the microphone rather than around the sides.)
3 Quality control
Whilst I appreciate it is a budget item, the quality control could be improved. The unit I received was covered in small damages from the manufacturer, including chipped and scratched paintwork, scuffed knobs, small areas of corrosion.
Conclusion
Overall, it works for it's intended purpose and will last a long time but there are some trade-off's with practicality and flexibility which will make it unsuitable for some setups.
1
0
Report
JN
Usefull novelty
Sturdy and well constructed. A bit heavy though, needs a sturdy stand, and probably without the use of a boom arm, at least not in a very open angle.
One of the clips that keeps it open was not in the right place to lock with the screw in mine (about 2mm off), easy to fix with a steel cutter, but had I not the powertool and the knowledge to use it would render that lock unscrewable, hence the whole contraption a little less well-locked, but by no means problematic. Same goes for some pre-drilled holes on the part that attaches to the mic stand, bit out of place.
Had not time to test it yet, but the foam is thick and dense, don't know which frequencies are absorbed and which are reflected (maybe some super highs are reflected, that's how dense it seems to me). Consider buying some foam panels of various density, shape and thickness to experiment with.
Obviously, a bit hard to have a score or a lyrics sheet right in front of you, I must train my customers (and myself) to strategically place the music stand above, below or around the thing.
I would love if there was a top and bottom part to absorb reflections from floor and ceiling, I think it can be achieved with minor design mods on the existing model.
All in all, it's built to last, the option of easily replacing the foam makes it usefull for a variety of situations, and it probably saves you from tampering with your room acoustics and the use of de-reverbing software.
Recomended.
One of the clips that keeps it open was not in the right place to lock with the screw in mine (about 2mm off), easy to fix with a steel cutter, but had I not the powertool and the knowledge to use it would render that lock unscrewable, hence the whole contraption a little less well-locked, but by no means problematic. Same goes for some pre-drilled holes on the part that attaches to the mic stand, bit out of place.
Had not time to test it yet, but the foam is thick and dense, don't know which frequencies are absorbed and which are reflected (maybe some super highs are reflected, that's how dense it seems to me). Consider buying some foam panels of various density, shape and thickness to experiment with.
Obviously, a bit hard to have a score or a lyrics sheet right in front of you, I must train my customers (and myself) to strategically place the music stand above, below or around the thing.
I would love if there was a top and bottom part to absorb reflections from floor and ceiling, I think it can be achieved with minor design mods on the existing model.
All in all, it's built to last, the option of easily replacing the foam makes it usefull for a variety of situations, and it probably saves you from tampering with your room acoustics and the use of de-reverbing software.
Recomended.
2
0
Report
R
Not for all rooms
I found I got a better sound just playing my guitar out into my living room. I have built panels for it and I have bass traps, so depending on your own room setup and your desired sound this will be more or less useful. It did make the sound more concentrated and louder when the mic was placed further into the absorber.
3
1
Report
T
Very good value for money!!
Easy to assemble! Stands good! Very nice tool for amateurs with non treated rooms. I've tested it on my AT2020 with and without it and it makes the difference! The built quality is very good and the quality of the foam is really nice!! It helps a lot at recordings!
0
0
Report
S
perfect
ik am so happy with this micscreen. its doing what is expected
0
0
Report
2
Pretty poor build quality, but does the job well for the price
0
0
Report
DA
OK for a small studio
The overall quality is good, although some of the locking hinges are sometimes hard to lock/unlock. It is rather bulky, but it folds down a bit smaller for storage when unused.
0
0
Report
D
Solution for studios without any sound proofing!
Works better than expected, quality is high and feels nice. But you must use a better stand, because it is pretty heavy for a cheap millenium one.
0
0
Report
B
From simplicity to professional sound
No more sound rooms made of mattresses, loved it very much.
I would strongly recommend it for any home setup where there is no room for a sound room.
I would strongly recommend it for any home setup where there is no room for a sound room.
0
0
Report
m
Does the job
Need a micscreen for voice recodring in my home studio. I can clearly hear the difference with / without the screen.
The build quality seems to be very good. But make sure you have a sturdy stand, because this micscreen is quite heavy. I wouldn't even consider placing it on a boom.
All in all I'm very happy with this one.
The build quality seems to be very good. But make sure you have a sturdy stand, because this micscreen is quite heavy. I wouldn't even consider placing it on a boom.
All in all I'm very happy with this one.
0
0
Report