10. Conclusion: Speakers or Headphones - What's Right for Me?
When musicians or bands start setting up their own monitoring system, the question arises: which form is the right choice?
Conventional monitoring is often the more budget-friendly option. The speakers themselves don't necessarily have to be cheaper, but it requires less equipment. With in-ear headphones typically having extremely high external noise reduction, it's advisable to mic up all instruments to hear them properly. This requires a lot of inputs on the mixing desk. Using monitor speakers might not necessitate miking up the drums and guitar amps; in many instances, they're loud enough. Consequently, monitoring with speakers is often preferred by musicians seeking that certain "live feeling" and direct interaction with the audience.
On the flip side, in-ear monitoring offers focused and quieter monitor sound - everywhere on stage - and a lower risk of feedback. Especially for musicians constantly on the move, an in-ear system should definitely be considered. It enhances performance and protects the ears from damage.
In practice, there are of course hybrid solutions too. Drummers and vocalists, for example, might use in-ear monitors, while the rest of the band uses monitor speakers. Some musicians also employ both forms simultaneously, providing redundancy in case the in-ear system fails. What one should avoid is switching between methods. Trying in-ear during rehearsals and then using monitors for a gig can lead to confusion. Since getting used to in-ear monitoring takes time, it's essential to consistently rehearse with it if planning to use it for live concerts.
When choosing the monitoring type, there's no right or wrong. Traditional monitoring with speakers always has this rock 'n' roll vibe. Young bands will often encounter wedges on stage in most cases. Even seasoned musicians enjoy working with conventional speakers. However, there's a reason why in-ear monitoring is gaining traction among the pros. For those safeguarding their hearing and craving crystal-clear audio without the feedback chaos, the shift to in-ear monitoring is the smart move.
For tailored recommendations, a one-on-one consultation is highly recommended. Our team in the sound department is always there to help. Visit us in person in Treppendorf or contact us by phone (09546/9223-35), chat, or email (pa@thomann.de).
